There is a fundamental conceptual collapse happening in some of the reviews of Rusty Ruins the Fort and Other Important Things:

THIS is the Impulse Intelligence process: emotion → emotional reaction → impulse → behavior

THIS is the collapse: emotion = emotional reaction = impulse = behavior


That is precisely the distinction the book is asking the reader to recognize.

An emotion is not the same thing as the reaction it produces. An emotional reaction is not necessarily an impulse. An impulse is not the same thing as the behavior that ultimately follows.

They can be connected without being identical.

And once those distinctions are collapsed, the Flickerlings are easily misread.

A reviewer sees an emotional event, sees a Flickerling respond, and concludes:

Flickerling = emotion.

But that isn’t the framework the book presents.

The Flickerlings exist to make the activity occurring between an event and a person’s eventual behavior visible. They can represent thoughts, interpretations, impulses, urges, warnings, memories, competing reactions, and other internal responses.

That is why the book says:

“thoughts, emotions, and impulses can compete for attention in the same moment.”

The word “and” matters.

Thoughts are not emotions.

Emotions are not impulses.

Impulses are not behavior.

They can all occur within the same moment, interact with one another, compete for attention, and influence what happens next.

That is the entire point.

So when a review describes the Flickerlings as though they are simply a collection of emotions and then criticizes the book for having “too many emotions,” the reviewer has collapsed the very distinctions the book is attempting to make visible.

The issue isn’t that the reviewer disagrees with the framework.

The issue is that the framework appears to have been changed before it was evaluated.

The process is not the collapse.

The distinction is the point.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

DOES EVIDENCE SHOW TRAINING IN IMPULSE CONTROL Helps Prevent Violent Aggression? The evidence is strongest for reducing aggression and improving self-regulation , rather than proving that impulse-control training prevents an individual murder or stabbing. A few particularly relevant findings: A systematic review/meta-analysis of 49 randomized trials involving 23,098 children and adolescents found that self-regulation interventions improved self-regulation, and reported improvements in behavioral problems, conduct disorders, and school suspensions among the studies measuring those outcomes.   https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2677898?utm_source=chatgpt.com#google_vignette  A randomized trial of 790 elementary-school children tested Second Step , a violence-prevention curriculum that explicitly taught anger management, impulse control, and empathy . Classroom observations showed a significant reduction in physical aggression , with most effects ...
Read more
  Introducing Impulse Intelligence™ We teach children not only about emotions, but also—and more importantly—what happens after the emotion: that gripping impulse that rises and feels like something they have to do. The Flickerlings approach teaches: EVENT → EMOTION → RECOGNIZE → NAME THE IMPULSE → PAUSE → CHOICE Impulse Intelligence™ gives children a way to recognize and name those impulses before they become actions. The Flickerlings make those invisible impulses visible—and give children a language for talking about them. This is the foundation of the Flickerling program.
Read more
 Impulse intelligence THE FLICKERLING DIFFERENCE Most programs teach: EVENT → EMOTION → REGULATE The missing piece: They often move from emotion directly to regulation without explicitly teaching the child to recognize and understand the impulse that comes between feeling and action. THE FLICKERLING DIFFERENCE teaches: EVENT → EMOTION → RECOGNIZE → NAME THE IMPULSE → PAUSE → CHOICE The child learns to recognize the impulse, name it, pause, and decide whether to act on it. Core idea: You can’t control an impulse you can’t recognize and name. FLICKERLINGS: A READING-BASED IMPULSE INTELLIGENCE PROGRAM The  B ridge between cute children’s book  and this is an actual program. Children read the story. 
 They meet the Flickerlings. 
 They hear the impulses out loud. 
 Then they learn to recognize, name, pause, and choose. Then give each adult a very clear job. TEACHERS Your role isn’t to lecture children about impulse control. You read the story and facilitate ...
Read more